My review of Arbit­ra­tion in Japan: A Practitioner’s Guide, edited by John Ribeiro and Lars Mark­ert, has been pub­lished in the Ger­man Arbit­ra­tion Journ­al (Zeits­chrift für Schieds­ver­fah­ren): SchiedsVZ 2026, 133–134 (sub­scrip­tion required). As the book itself is writ­ten for an inter­na­tion­al read­er­ship, here is my trans­la­tion of the review into English.

Patrick Dahm reading Arbitration in Japan: A Practitioner’s Guide, edited by John Ribeiro and Lars Markert

Arbit­ra­tion in Japan: A Practitioner’s Guide, John Ribeiro/Lars Mark­ert (eds.), Kluwer Law Inter­na­tion­al. 2026. ISBN 9789403520254.

Arbit­ra­tion prac­ti­tion­ers in Asia rarely encounter Japan as a seat of arbit­ra­tion, but far more often as the home of parties who take their cross-bor­der dis­putes else­where. Yet Japan does have an arbit­ra­tion sys­tem: it is leg­ally sound and shaped by Ger­man influ­ences, though under­pinned by a leg­al mar­ket that, at least domest­ic­ally, is not par­tic­u­larly liti­gi­ous. It oper­ates, how­ever, in the shad­ow of the arbit­ra­tion centres that now dom­in­ate the Asia-Pacific region: Singa­pore, Hong Kong and, more recently and with grow­ing determ­in­a­tion, Kuala Lum­pur and Seoul. Not to men­tion China, which in many respects belongs in a cat­egory of its own.

There is also no short­age of over­views that present Japan as a seat of arbit­ra­tion from a non-Japan­ese per­spect­ive.[1] Com­mend­able as they are, they are by their nature con­cise. Until now, there has been no com­pre­hens­ive ref­er­ence work that cov­ers the full scope of the Japan­ese arbit­ra­tion sys­tem for a non-Japan­ese-speak­ing spe­cial­ist audi­ence. This volume, edited by Lars Mark­ert and John Ribeiro – two arbit­ra­tion law­yers who have been prac­tising in Japan for many years – aims to fill this gap. It succeeds.

Insiders

This Eng­lish-lan­guage book is divided into four parts. The first part com­prises Chapters 1 to 4, which deal with Japan as a seat of inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion. The second part con­sists of a brief com­ment­ary on the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act. The third part com­prises four­teen chapters on selec­ted top­ics, ran­ging from applic­able law, the pro­duc­tion of doc­u­ments and hybrid pro­ceed­ings, to sports, con­struc­tion, IP and invest­ment arbit­ra­tion, as well as third-party fund­ing and train­ing in arbit­ra­tion law. The fourth part con­sists of the edit­ors’ own Eng­lish trans­la­tion of the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act, which delib­er­ately departs from the Min­istry of Justice’s semi-offi­cial trans­la­tion – which, the edit­ors say, inter­na­tion­al prac­ti­tion­ers find hard to use – and instead aligns with the ter­min­o­logy of the UNCITRAL Mod­el Law and cur­rent inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion practice.

All the con­tri­bu­tions are by law­yers and leg­al schol­ars based in Japan, of both Japan­ese and non-Japan­ese ori­gin. The work thus com­bines an insider’s per­spect­ive with an outsider’s view – a com­bin­a­tion that works to its advant­age. The book was more than three years in the mak­ing: con­ceived before the recent reform of the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act, it was com­pleted with renewed urgency as that reform took shape. It is up to date: the amend­ments to the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act, which came into force on 1 April 2024, are taken into account through­out, and the newly estab­lished spe­cial­ised arbit­ra­tion cham­bers at the Dis­trict Courts of Tokyo and Osaka are also mentioned.

Homework

The book paints a nuanced pic­ture of arbit­ra­tion in Japan. On the one hand, Japan has done its home­work. The Arbit­ra­tion Act has been reformed on sev­er­al occa­sions and now com­plies with the cur­rent stand­ards of the UNCITRAL Mod­el Law. The courts are regarded as arbit­ra­tion-friendly. The Japan Com­mer­cial Arbit­ra­tion Asso­ci­ation (JCAA) has repeatedly mod­ern­ised its arbit­ra­tion rules and offers two dis­tinct sets of rules, includ­ing the Inter­act­ive Arbit­ra­tion Rules, which ‘innov­at­ively’ adopt a pro­ced­ur­al approach more closely aligned with civil law (though these were intro­duced after the Prague Rules on the Effi­cient Con­duct of Pro­ceed­ings in Inter­na­tion­al Arbit­ra­tion and, in that respect, can­not claim to be innov­at­ive, at least not in the strict sense). For­eign law­yers have been per­mit­ted to rep­res­ent parties in inter­na­tion­ally ori­ented arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings since 1996, and the rules have been gradu­ally relaxed since. Tokyo and Osaka, in par­tic­u­lar, offer mod­ern arbit­ra­tion infra­struc­ture at prices that are com­pet­it­ive with those of oth­er Asi­an arbit­ra­tion centres.

Reality Check

On the oth­er hand, the JCAA’s case­load has remained low for years, well below what one might expect giv­en Japan’s eco­nom­ic sig­ni­fic­ance. The chapter authors note this, and sev­er­al of them attempt to put it into con­text: Japan­ese com­pan­ies are cer­tainly involved in inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings, just not in Japan. The reform momentum of recent years, they argue, should be meas­ured not by case num­bers but by the grow­ing famili­ar­ity of Japan­ese prac­ti­tion­ers with inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion prac­tice and by their increas­ing insti­tu­tion­al self-confidence.

This is a fair account, if some­what optim­ist­ic in places. An out­side per­spect­ive sug­gests that the com­pet­i­tion among arbit­ra­tion seats can­not be won by catch-up reforms alone. Singa­pore, for example, has main­tained and expan­ded its lead­ing pos­i­tion as an arbit­ra­tion centre not least through con­tinu­ous innov­a­tion. Ambi­tious com­pet­it­ors such as Seoul and Kuala Lum­pur (Islam­ic fin­ance arbit­ra­tion) are also invest­ing heav­ily in their arbit­ra­tion infra­struc­ture, though without, so far, achiev­ing com­par­able inter­na­tion­al vis­ib­il­ity. Against this back­drop, it is not imme­di­ately clear from read­ing the book why Japan in par­tic­u­lar – which cur­rently ranks, at best, in the middle of the pack among inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion centres and has so far shown little vis­ible innov­a­tion bey­ond har­mon­isa­tion with inter­na­tion­al stand­ards – should gain sig­ni­fic­antly in import­ance solely through reforms and sup­port meas­ures. This does not detract from the value of the work. How­ever, it is a ques­tion that keeps com­ing up while read­ing the book.

Bridge

The real mer­it of this work lies not in answer­ing wheth­er Japan will become a pop­u­lar seat of arbit­ra­tion, but in its func­tion as a lin­guist­ic and intel­lec­tu­al bridge. Japan­ese arbit­ra­tion law is, not least because of the lan­guage bar­ri­er, largely inac­cess­ible to non-Japan­ese prac­ti­tion­ers. What does exist there – a mod­ern arbit­ra­tion act, dec­ades of arbit­ra­tion prac­tice, judi­cial case law – has, until now, been hid­den behind a lin­guist­ic veil. This work lifts that veil.

The book is par­tic­u­larly valu­able where it sheds light on the unex­pec­ted. For instance, one chapter devotes con­sid­er­able space to the ques­tion of what to make of doc­u­ment pro­duc­tion in arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings influ­enced by Japan­ese law – a prac­tice which, in Japan­ese civil pro­ced­ure (as in con­tin­ent­al European leg­al sys­tems), is known only to a lim­ited extent, but is firmly estab­lished in inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion. The chapter’s answer is that it depends on the extent to which the pro­ceed­ings are influ­enced by Japan­ese prac­tice and how famil­i­ar the parties are with inter­na­tion­al stand­ards. Simple as it is (and it will, of course, need refin­ing in each case), this is an extremely prac­tic­al answer. Equally prac­tic­al is the in-depth dis­cus­sion of leg­al pro­fes­sion­al priv­ilege: in Japan, unlike in com­mon law jur­is­dic­tions, it applies only to a very lim­ited extent, which is of dir­ect rel­ev­ance to prac­ti­tion­ers and arbit­rat­ors from Eng­land, Singa­pore or any oth­er com­mon law jur­is­dic­tion. The chapter also men­tions the prac­tice, typ­ic­al in Japan, of estab­lish­ing inde­pend­ent invest­ig­a­tion com­mit­tees (third-party com­mit­tees), which are appoin­ted in the event of com­pli­ance incid­ents with­in a com­pany and whose reports are to some extent pub­lic in nature: the author rightly describes the ques­tion of wheth­er these reports could be regarded as priv­ileged in arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings as open and unre­solved. For prac­ti­tion­ers pre­par­ing for arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings with a Japan­ese fla­vour, such insights are of con­sid­er­able value.

The same applies to the chapter on the dif­fer­ence between domest­ic and inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings in Japan – a dis­tinc­tion which the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act itself does not make, but which does in fact exist. Accord­ing to the authors’ anec­dot­al obser­va­tions, domest­ic pro­ceed­ings have tra­di­tion­ally been heav­ily mod­elled on Japan­ese civil pro­ced­ure – a sys­tem with which a Ger­man civil pro­ced­ure spe­cial­ist may well be famil­i­ar in some respects: plead­ings sub­mit­ted in stages rather than a com­pre­hens­ive exchange of plead­ings, and less struc­tured case man­age­ment. Any­one com­ing from the field of inter­na­tion­al com­mer­cial arbit­ra­tion who finds them­selves involved in a Japan­ese-style pro­ceed­ing for the first time would do well to get to know this approach.

Three Chapters

Three chapters deserve spe­cial men­tion, as they exem­pli­fy the strengths – and, on occa­sion, the weak­nesses – of the work.

For me, the chapter on hybrid pro­ced­ures (Arb-Med-Arb and related arrange­ments) is one of the most insight­ful. The authors explain that the his­tor­ic­al value placed on social har­mony – a leg­acy of the Tok­ugawa era and deeply rooted in Japan­ese leg­al cul­ture – has an impact on civil pro­ceed­ings and, by exten­sion, on arbit­ra­tion: a Japan­ese arbit­rat­or is always a poten­tial medi­at­or as well. This is accur­ately observed, and use­ful for a non-Japan­ese prac­ti­tion­er tak­ing part in such pro­ceed­ings to know. The authors’ view that this approach can help counter one of the greatest short­com­ings of mod­ern inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion – namely its cost – deserves whole­hearted endorsement.

The chapter on investor-state dis­pute set­tle­ment high­lights an inter­est­ing para­dox: with over fifty invest­ment pro­tec­tion agree­ments in place, Japan is one of the world’s most pro­lif­ic sig­nat­or­ies of such agree­ments. How­ever, recourse to the arbit­ra­tion mech­an­isms provided for in these agree­ments has so far been min­im­al. Japan has been the respond­ent in only one ISDS case. This can be inter­preted in vari­ous ways: as an indic­a­tion of a leg­al mar­ket that is gen­er­ally law-abid­ing or dis­pute-averse, but also as a sign that Japan’s bilat­er­al eco­nom­ic rela­tions rarely give rise to the points of fric­tion that lead to ISDS claims else­where. The chapter ana­lyses this thor­oughly, without draw­ing hasty conclusions.

The chapter on mari­time arbit­ra­tion is a dif­fer­ent mat­ter. The fact that the Tokyo Mari­time Arbit­ra­tion Com­mis­sion (TOMAC), foun­ded in 1926, has the longest his­tory of any Japan­ese arbit­ra­tion insti­tu­tion, and that its pro­ceed­ings are designed as a more cost-effect­ive and faster altern­at­ive to the Lon­don Mari­time Arbit­rat­ors Asso­ci­ation, is presen­ted in an inform­at­ive and con­vin­cing man­ner. Less con­vin­cing, how­ever, is the authors’ con­clud­ing assess­ment that the TOMAC has the poten­tial to assume a lead­ing role in mari­time arbit­ra­tion in Asia. It remains unclear why an insti­tu­tion with a hun­dred-year his­tory, which has not yet suc­ceeded in doing so, should achieve such a pos­i­tion in the future. As a res­ult, the assess­ment reads less like ana­lys­is than like an appeal.

Wish List

Now for a few crit­ic­al remarks. In edited volumes, the risk of repe­ti­tion is inher­ent in the very struc­ture of the work. When many authors write about a lim­ited area of law, over­laps are almost inev­it­able. Here too, some chapters cov­er ground already covered else­where. For­tu­nately, this is kept with­in bounds and does not detract from the over­all impression.

Some chapters also indulge their interest in leg­al his­tory a little too much. The chapter on rep­res­ent­a­tion in arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings, for example, provides an inform­at­ive but very detailed account of how the Act on the Admis­sion of For­eign Law­yers came about, from the dip­lo­mat­ic pres­sure exer­ted by the USA and the European Com­munit­ies in the early 1990s right up to the most recent reforms. For the for­eign prac­ti­tion­er who wishes to know wheth­er and under what con­di­tions they may appear in Tokyo or Osaka, this is of lim­ited use. The same applies to parts of the chapter on exped­ited arbit­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings. In a future edi­tion, it would be worth con­sid­er­ing a more con­cise account of the legis­lat­ive his­tory in favour of a more in-depth ana­lys­is of the law as it may then stand.

Commentary

The brief com­ment­ary on the Arbit­ra­tion Act – the second part of the work – deserves sep­ar­ate men­tion. The edit­ors and authors have, in the words of a Ger­man civil pro­ced­ure schol­ar, mod­elled it more on the Zöller than on the München­er Kom­ment­ar (or, in the words of an inter­na­tion­al arbit­ra­tion prac­ti­tion­er, more on Red­fern and Hunter than on Born): con­cise, focused on the essen­tials and sup­ple­men­ted by ref­er­ences to the pur­pose and legis­lat­ive his­tory of each pro­vi­sion, as well as to rel­ev­ant case law, where avail­able. For a found­a­tion­al work of this kind, this is the right edit­or­i­al decision. Any­one enga­ging with the Japan­ese Arbit­ra­tion Act for the first time or seek­ing guid­ance on a spe­cif­ic issue – such as the pay­ment of a pen­alty in the event of non-com­pli­ance with an inter­im order issued by an arbit­ral tribunal[2] – will find this com­ment­ary an indis­pens­able resource.

Verdict

Hav­ing pre­vi­ously known Japan mainly from the per­spect­ive of its ‘neigh­bour­ing’ arbit­ra­tion centres, I found that read­ing Arbit­ra­tion in Japan broadened my under­stand­ing and sur­prised me on sev­er­al occa­sions. This is surely one of the aims of such a work, and it has been achieved. The edit­ors deserve cred­it for their pion­eer­ing work, which, as they openly admit in the intro­duct­ory chapter, took sev­er­al years of their spare time and count­less even­ings to com­plete. The same goes for the authors, whose con­tri­bu­tions have pro­duced a work that fills a genu­ine gap in the literature.

Wheth­er Japan will emerge as a major centre for arbit­ra­tion remains to be seen. The struc­tur­al obstacles are real, the com­pet­i­tion is fierce, and the optim­ism of some authors does not seem entirely jus­ti­fied – at least from the per­spect­ive of a ‘neigh­bour­ing’ arbit­ra­tion hub. But that is a dif­fer­ent ques­tion from wheth­er this book is worth read­ing – and on that, there is no doubt. This work is highly recom­men­ded to arbit­ra­tion prac­ti­tion­ers who deal with Japan or Japan­ese parties, or who may come to do so, as well as to leg­al schol­ars spe­cial­ising in this field.


[1] For Ger­man-speak­ing spe­cial­ists, examples include the coun­try chapter by Mueller in: Salger/Trittmann, Inter­na­tionale Schieds­ver­fah­ren, 2019, § 24, paras. 1258–1325, as well as Mark­ert, SchiedsVZ 2026, 11; SchiedsVZ 2019, 242; ZJapanR 2017, 111; SchiedsVZ 2016, 15.

[2] See also Mark­ert, SchiedsVZ 2026, 11, 16.


Trans­lated by the review­er from the Ger­man ori­gin­al, first pub­lished in SchiedsVZ 2026, 133–134.